Helen Van Dale: A woman of the criminal underworld Part I

Most individuals living in the Quad Cities are familiar with the name John Looney. From his home base across the Mississippi River in Rock Island, Illinois, Looney created an illegal empire that included gambling, prostitution, protection money, and illegal alcohol starting in the early 1900s. His control included Rock Island, Davenport, and surrounding towns.

It was only with his permission that “disorderly houses” or “resorts” (which involved gambling, prostitution, and later illegal alcohol) could be opened. Protection fees were paid by the owners to Looney along with his input in how many women could work at the resorts and who supplied the alcohol to the establishments. Many of these businesses operated under legal business titles such as soft drink parlors, boarding houses, or hotels.

Looney’s underworld empire flourished until 1922, when the murder of saloon owner William “Bill” Gable on July 31st of that year led to a gang war that soon resulted in the death of Looney’s only son and the arrest of notable underworld figures including Looney himself. However, this blog isn’t about John Looney, but someone else.

One woman played a central role in this criminal world from the late 1910s into the early 1920s. Her name was Helen Van Dale. She arrived in the Quad Cities an unknown young woman soon involved in prostitution, but Helen would rise to local prominence by the early 1920s, so the rumor goes, as the one person John Looney feared.

Then just as quickly as Helen Van Dale became a frequent headline in local history, she disappeared into the unknown until 2019.

With a few genealogical clues, we were finally able to piece the details of Helen’s life together and have an ending to her story. We thought we would share her story in her birthday month of July. We will only touch on the underworld crime scene of the Quad Cities in the late 1910s into the 1920s here, but we strongly encourage readers to do more research on this fascinating subject.

We have put together a history of Helen Van Dale’s life and the lives of those involved with her for this blog.

On July 18, 1893, Eula Elizabeth Lee was born in Paris, Edgar County, Illinois near the Indiana border to James P. and Nancy J. Lee.  Through U.S. Census research, we find in 1900 the family of three living in Paris, Illinois with James working as a day laborer. By the 1910 U.S. Census, the family had grown with the birth of Eula’s sister, Dimples (as recorded in the census record), in 1902. The family had left Paris and moved to Galesburg, Knox County, Illinois near the Rock Island/Davenport area. James Lee was now a fireman working with the railroad.

When Eula was about 17 years old, the United States government passed the Mann Act on June 25, 1910. This Act prohibited the transport of girls and women for the purpose of prostitution or debauchery. This Act would later have a major impact on Eula’s life.

Eula married Robert J. Rathburn in 1913. The marriage took place in Knox County, Illinois.

We learn from the 1910 U.S. Census that then 19-year-old Robert lived in Moline, Illinois and worked for the U.S. Government as a Lock Tender. We think as Robert was working for the Rock Island Arsenal in 1917 according to his WWI draft card that after the marriage the couple returned to Rock Island, Illinois to live.

We have not currently located a record for a divorce between Robert and Eula. We think their marriage was brief and divorce likely occurred in Rock Island County, Illinois. It was during this time that Eula began to use Katherine Helen/Catherine Helen as her first and middle names. She used Katherine/Catherine mainly on official documents for the rest of her life while Helen became the name she used daily. Occasionally, she added an “-e” to the end and went by Helene.

In December 1914, a Mrs. Mary Van Dale of Rock Island, Illinois filed for divorce from her husband, Henry. She asked for custody of their only child. The reason for the divorce was Henry, a bartender, had become involved with Helen Howard who operated a restaurant at 2109 Fourth Avenue.

We believe Helen Howard was the former Eula Lee Rathburn. We know in May 1915 from newspaper records that a Helen Howard was arrested and fined $25 and costs for running a “disorderly house” called Waukeska located in Rock Island on 16th Street between 1st and 2nd Avenues. Interestingly, a Lester Smith was also arrested in the raid. They were both arrested by Detective Tom Cox of the Rock Island Police Department. Both men would have a greater place in Helen’s life in the near future.

Helen Howard continued to be in the newspapers during 1915, arrested for running “disorderly houses”. The newspapers mention that once a house was shut down in Rock Island, the girls would leave town for Davenport until an arrest there would have them returning to Rock Island.

The Daily Times, May 17, 1915. Pg. 14

Finally, on August 3, 1915, Mrs. Mary Van Dale was granted a divorce from Henry in Rock Island County, Illinois on grounds of adultery with Helen Howard. On August 23, 1915, Catherine Helen Lee married Henry G. Van Dale in Clinton, Iowa. From this point on, Helen Howard disappears from local newspapers and Helen Van Dale takes her place.

Over the next few years, Helen must have gained favor with John Looney as she soon operated multiple “disorderly houses” in Rock Island and Davenport with girls being moved between the establishments.

In June of 1918, we find the record of a Mrs. Florence Smith filing for and receiving a divorce in Rock Island County from her unfaithful husband Lester “Society” Smith. This is the same Lester Smith arrested in 1915 at the Waukeska with Helen. Soon after the divorce, Lester Charles Smith served in the military from September 3, 1918, through November 27, 1918. After discharge, he returned to Rock Island.

In April 1919, Catherine H. Van Dale filed for divorce charging her husband, Henry,  had married her within a year of his previous divorce.

The Daily Times, April 3, 1919. Pg. 16.

On May 1, 1919, Detective Tom Cox (who arrested Helen Van Dale and Lester Smith at the Waukeska in 1915) was promoted to Police Chief of Rock Island.

On May 9, 1919, Helen Van Dale and Lester Charles Smith were married.

Soon after their marriage, Lester “Society” Smith began to appear frequently in the newspapers for various arrests.

Helen Smith filed for and received a divorce from Lester Smith on January 15, 1920.

Around the time of her divorce from Smith, rumors began that Helen Van Dale (as she was commonly known) was keeping company with Police Chief Tom Cox. Another local rumor was Cox began to spend a great deal of time in girlfriend Helen’s establishments, which were filled with Looney associates.

Between 1918 and 1919, Helen’s parents divorced in Galesburg, Illinois. Her mother and younger sister (identified in the 1920 U.S. Census by her real name Lillis Lee) moved to Davenport and began to help Helen with her growing business of “disorderly houses”.

Lillis (also known as Dimples or Edna Smith), gave birth to her first son with Victor Joseph Ciesielski in October 1920. She married Ciesielski in February 1921 in Scott County, Iowa. Victor, known by the alias Heinie Lee, was involved with Looney’s operation and worked in Helen’s establishments. They would divorce in June 1923 with Lillis receiving custody of their two children.

Helen most likely needed the help of her mother and sister as her businesses grew. Her mother and sister seemed to manage to Davenport part of the business while Helen oversaw Rock Island. Two of her most important houses were the Palmer Inn in the Nahant Road area of Davenport and the building at 2327 Fourth Avenue in Rock Island. Originally, the focus of these establishments most likely involved gambling and prostitution with John Looney using various methods of corruption to keep everyone in line with him.

With the passage of the 18th Amendment and the start of Prohibition on January 17, 1920, a new element was added into local disorderly houses and underworld crime as bootlegging and illegal alcohol became a new source of revenue to fight over.

By 1922, Helen was a successful figure in underworld crime. She appears protected by both John Looney and Tom Cox. But not everyone was happy with the special treatment Helen received. One individual who was growing tired of Looney and Van Dale was William “Bill” Gable who owned a “soft drink parlor” and “resort” next to Helen at 2319 Fourth Avenue, Rock Island.

While Helen was rarely raided on the Rock Island side of her business (Davenport raids were frequent), Gable was raided by the Rock Island Police several times and was still paying protection fees and other fees to Looney. Helen’s fees were reduced or nonexistent.

Whispers began that by late spring 1922, Gable wanted out. He wanted to leave the underworld scene behind him and start legitimate businesses. More whispers began that he had seen something in Helen’s Fourth Avenue establishment involving Tom Cox. Other whispers stated he was talking to Federal Agents and had been given police protection. 

It was nearly midnight on the night of July 31, 1922, when Gable drove to his establishment at 2319 Fourth Avenue and parked his car. He got out, walked around his vehicle and stepped on the sidewalk. No one knows if he knew a large car had been following him that night. His police protection having been told to stay at the station for duty. 

Six men reportedly appeared from the shadows and two opened fire. Gable fell dead on the sidewalk.

The Davenport Democrat, August 1, 1922. Pg. 1

The world of Helen Van Dale and her colleagues was about to change.

Who will talk? Who will stay silent? 

And what does the future hold for Helen Van Dale?

Part II will appear the week of July 22, 2019.

(posted by Amy D.)

 

Resources:

  • United States Census Records, Marriage Records, and World War I Draft Card information found on Ancestry.Com
  • The Rock Island Argus, Rock Island, Illinois. December 26, 1914. Pg. 12
  • The Daily Times, Davenport, Iowa. May 17, 1915. Pg. 4
  • The Rock Island Argus, Rock Island, Illinois. July 21, 1915. Pg. 5
  • The Rock Island Argus, Rock Island, Illinois. June 26, 1918. Pg. 5
  • The Daily Times, Davenport, Iowa. April 3, 1919. Pg. 16.
  • The Rock Island Argus, Rock Island, Illinois. March 10, 1919. Pg. 3
  • The Rock Island Argus, Rock Island, Illinois. May 10, 1919. Pg. 16
  • The Daily Times, Davenport, Iowa. February 5, 1921. Pg. 16
  • The Davenport Democrat, August 1, 1922. Pg. 1

This entry was posted in Genealogy, Local History and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *